“So, what happened at lunch?” Ms. Marlowe pressed.
“Well, the plan went off without a hitch, except as soon as Pedro and Clay talked about it they smoothed it out immediately. Not a very complex plan, really. And then of course Hero and Clay did end up dating, so, like I’ve been saying, you’re making a big deal out of nothing. I guess the big thing that went down at lunch, and we did not plan this, was Ben and Beatrice’s thing.”
“Their thing?” Dr. Burbage asked.
“Okay, so here’s what happened. And look, I wasn’t there for all of it, but Margaret heard from Hero some of it, and John told me what he did, so I’m sort of piecing it all together.”
A busy cafeteria. Noisy students, long tables, plastic chairs, and grimy trays. The basketball set are in one quadrant, Hero is across the room but visible to them, the drama set is in the corner, watching and waiting.
“Here’s the plan,” Pedro told Clay at their table. “I’m going to call you, but leave my phone in my pocket so you can hear everything she says. Like a walkie-talkie, get it?”
“Okay, yeah!” he agreed. “Be…cool though, right? Don’t tell her it’s me that likes her until you know how she feels. Please.”
Ben rolled his eyes. “This is dumb as hell.”
“Don’t listen to him, what could go wrong?” Pedro argued with imperfect logic.
“Don’t forget to put it on mute though,” Ben told them.
They dialed and Pedro slipped his cracked up phone into his pocket and, pounding his soda, rose up like a soldier going off to war. “Wish me luck.” He began to walk away, but turned back. Burped loudly. And on he went.
“Yes, what could go wrong?” Ben laughed.
Clay was beginning to have misgivings. He hit mute.
The two huddled over Clay’s phone.
“Listen!” Clay said. “What is that swooshing?”
“It’s just him walking still, see?” Ben pointed to where Pedro had paused midway across the cafeteria to say hey to Balthasar, the band kid. Ben was facing where Hero sat, but Clay’s back was to her.
“Can you hear them?” Clay asked, scrunching up his face in concentration.
“No, but he’s walking again. I just realized I’ve never been this close to Pedro’s schlong before. We have a schlong-side seat to the great Hero set up. You know what, I’m out.” He shook his head. “Are you done? I’ll take your trash.”
Say what you will about Ben, he does do little things like that that are kind of nice.
Clay casually turned and leaned back against the table, holding up his phone to his ear as if he were talking to someone.
So John, seeing this and using it to his advantage, went up to Verges, you know, the Hall Monitor.
“Hey, Verges? I know that Clay kid is new, so he probably doesn’t know that phones aren’t allowed in the cafeteria. Should I say something?”
Nodding solemnly, the dork went off to confront Clay, who had to hang up the phone and put it in his bag, lest Verges go and get an actual teacher to confiscate it.
Then John sidled up to Clay, who was watching Hero and Pedro.
“Hi. Clay, right? I’m Pedro’s half-brother, John.”
“Oh, hey, man.” But Clay was distracted and kept watching.
Pretending to just catch sight of Pedro and Hero, John continued. “Oh, good he’s finally talking to her.”
“What do you mean?”
“Pedro’s liked Hero for a long time, but didn’t want to ruin their friendship.”
“Huh?”
“I wonder what made him finally ask her out?”
“No, that’s not what he’s doing…” Clay protested weakly.
“Are you sure? It looks to me like they’re getting along pretty well over there.”
“And indeed his timing was perfect, because Hero had just leaned over and given Pedro a hug with a smile on her cute little face. What had really happened though was exactly what Pedro had promised. He went over, although he stopped to ask Balthasar for the answers to the test in Chem, which Balthasar had in the morning, but Pedro had next. You know, you guys should really look into the rampant cheating on sports teams. I mean, you look the other way, because your athletes need to keep up their GPAs to play, but what you’re really doing is depriving them of their education.”
“Get on with it,” Dr. Kepler, the Chem teacher, prompted.
“Right. But Pedro really does cheat a lot. Anyway.”
“Why is John staring over here?” Ursula asked the girls at their table.
They all turned to see him watching, still and silent.
“Ew,” Beatrice muttered, turning back. “That bastard throws more shade than an umbrella.”
“I don’t know,” Hero said. “I just think he looks kind of melancholy.”
“Melancholy?” teased Beatrice with a little laugh.
“S.A.T. word,” Hero threw back at her. “It means sad.”
“I know what it means,” Beatrice replied, throwing a grape at her friend.
“Hey!” But Hero had the grace to laugh it off.
“I’ll tell you what, if there were a guy halfway between John’s smug Eeyore-ness and Ben’s obnoxious all-American good guy routine…”
“Oooh,” joined in Ursula. “Ben’s hair and height, John’s luscious lips…”
“And if he were rich, could play guitar, and loved dogs, he’d be the perfect man,” Beatrice finished. “Alas. No such luck.”
“You’re never going to get a boyfriend with that attitude,” Ursula admonished her.
“Good! I’m glad. I’d be bored in a minute with most of these idiots. And I would never date a guy with a beard,” she added as a stoner with a sad scruff of a beard slouched by.
“So date a guy without,” Hero suggested.
Beatrice made a face as if offended. “And do what with him? I want a manly kind of a man.”
Together they surveyed all the guys around the cafeteria.
She continued her assessment. “Guys with beards look older, and that’s hot. Guys without look babyish. But I don’t want to date an older man, not until college. And, well, younger guys don’t want to date me!” she said as if wielding a threat.
Ursula sighed dramatically. “Well I don’t have a date for prom either.”
“What about you, Hero? Anyone caught your eye?” Beatrice asked.
She shrugged sort of helplessly.
Ursula didn’t let it go. “You’ll see, Beatrice. Some guy asks you and…” she snapped her fingers, “you’ll be picking out corsages.”
“I’ll go to college single. I want to keep my options open. But hold on. Hero is still blushing. That’s a lot, even for you. Tell! Tell!”
Hero shook her head, her glossy hair falling in front of her face like a curtain. “No it’s nothing.”
“Tell!” Ursula echoed.
They looked at each other and started chanting together: “Tell us! Tell us! Tell us!”
Hero laughed. “Okay, okay, just shut up already.”
All giggles, the three leaned in to whisper.
“Well,” she began, “I think Clay is pretty cute…”
“Ooooh,” her friends gushed, peeking over at him. He was so busy trying to coordinate his attack with Pedro that he totally missed it.
“Shhh! But…well, I overheard them talking this morning in English…”
“What?” Beatrice asked her.
“Maybe it’s nothing,” Hero answered. “But, I heard Pedro say he thought I was awesome and he was going to ask me out, or something.”
“Pedro!” Ursula gasped.
“Yeah. I don’t know what to do. I don’t want to hurt his feelings. But also, like, he and Clay are friends. Oh, I don’t know,” and Hero buried her face in her hands.
“Girl, you had better decide quickly, because here he comes!” Beatrice warned. “Do you want us to stay or go?”
“Ah! I don’t know, I don’t know…yes, go. Please. Thank you!”
“What are you going to say?” Ursula whispered loudly.
“Hey, Hero,” Pedro said smoothly. “Mind if I sit?”
“You can have my seat,” Beatrice volunteered, “I have to drop by the library. Come on, Ursula. We have that book we need to get.”
“Thanks,” Pedro said as she left, pulling Ursula with her.
“We haven’t talked for a while, huh?” he mentioned to Hero. “How are things?”
“Um, fine.” There was an awkward pause. “How, uh, how are you?”
“Never better. Anyway. Are you seeing anyone?” he blurted out.
Hero drew in a deep breath, and with all the kindness she could muster, she laid a hand gently on his arm. “Pedro, I heard you this morning. In English class. I think you’re really great, and I’m glad we’re friends and all, but…”
“What? Oh. No, not me. I mean, yeah you’re really great. Friends. Yeah, I mean we’re friends and all, but no. It’s not me.”
“Oh. Who?” she asked nervously, glancing around.
“Are you? Seeing anyone?”
“No, Pedro, I’m not. But you know how important school is to me, to my family. I’m really focused on that right now. I don’t really know if I should be dating anyone right now.”
“Oh, okay. Yeah.” He got up to leave. “It’s just, my boy Clay really likes you,” he added throwing caution to the wind.
“Clay? Clay Osborne?” and a smile stole across her face, crinkling her eyes warmly.
He laughed a bit nervously. “Yeah. Unless you don’t like him back. Then forget I said anything.”
Now they were leaning toward each other and smiling, comfortable at last, now that they were speaking honestly.
“Well, what I said is true. I have to stay focused on school. I don’t want to lose my class standing. I mean it’s Harvard…”
“Sooooo…?”
After a moment’s thought, she capitulated. “I think he’s really cute. What do you think? Is he, you know, a good guy?”
“He’s the best! He’s a cool dude,” he added, reining himself in. “What should I tell him?”
“Yes. Yes, I like Clay. If he asked me out, I would say yes.”
And she was so excited she flung herself into Pedro’s arms for a big ole hug.
Across the cafeteria, Clay stormed off to go sulk in the gym.
When Ben had left the cafeteria he went to his locker, whistling a merry little tune and laughing to himself at how stupid Pedro’s plan was. He was shaping jokes in his head along the lines of “I’ll call you Bond, James Bond,” when Balthasar exited, looking sort of put out.
And an idea popped into his pretty head. “Oh, hey there, buddy!”
Balthasar visibly cringed. Yet when an athlete at the top of his game and easily clearing six feet summons you, when he’s cool and you’re, well, in band, you go where you’re summoned.
“Could you do me a favor? You know, as a friend?” Ben asked.
“Um, what is it?” he ventured.
“I need to call your phone and then you put your phone in your pocket so I can listen in.”
“Oh, um. On what?”
Ben looked over his shoulder to make sure no one saw him talking to Balthasar. “I want you to ask Beatrice about me.”
“Oh, that’s easy. She hates your guts.” Then the poor guy quailed under the look Ben gave him.
“Yeah, well. Just bring me up casually, no big deal, and see what she says.”
“Why?”
Ben ignored him. “And don’t tell anyone I asked. Least of all her. Or Pedro.”
With a sigh, Balthasar pulled out his phone. He was ‘O’ for two.
Thus, with his makeshift eavesdropping device, Ben sent his new buddy into the witch’s lair, there to meet with Beatrice.
A library. Students bent over books and papers, scrawling. One student sleeps atop a pile of books, drool seeping from their gaping mouth.
“Uh, hi,” Balthasar began lamely.
Ben leaned into his phone, speaker pressed hard against his ear. He slipped into the bathroom, so as not to have his phone confiscated.
“Hi?” Beatrice responded.
“We had Trig together last year. I sat behind you. Not right behind, but a few seats back.”
“Right…”
The stare she gave him made him uncomfortably aware of how weird he seemed.
Desperate, he looked at the paper she was writing. “Is that for Ms. Leonato’s class? I have her third period.”
“Yeah, it’s the poem. For homework.”
“Can I hear it?” he asked, his curiosity getting the better of him.
“Sure. It’s not finished. It goes:
‘Sigh no more, ladies, sigh no more.
Men were deceivers ever,
One foot in sea, and one on shore,
To one thing constant never.
Then sigh not so, but let them go,
Converting all your sounds of woe
Into hey nonny, nonny.’”
“What’s a nonny?” was Balthasar’s first reaction.
“I don’t know, it just sounds like something Shakespeare would say,” she said defensively.
“Yeah, totally,” he agreed. “Cool.”
And with nothing else to say, he stood there awkwardly.
“Did you want something?” she finally prodded him, sounding annoyed.
“No. Uh, yes. No. Uh, is your poem about Ben?”
She rolled her eyes as profoundly as she could manage.
“Why? Do you know him?” was her cryptic reply.
“Sure, everyone knows Ben.”
Beatrice put on her sweet, most saccharine simpering smile. “Yes, everyone knows Ben. He likes to play the part of the class clown. Except the problem is, he isn’t funny. Somehow he thinks everyone likes him, but he has to change friends so often because no one can stand him for long. No one but the losers and burnouts like him, but only because even they can laugh at him behind his back, strutting around the school like an idiot.”
From Balthasar’s pocket came a muffled: “what the actual ffff…”
“What was that?” Beatrice snapped.
“Nothing, nothing,” Balthasar stammered.
From his hiding place, Ben scrambled to mute himself. He had failed to take his own advice.
“Uh, should I not tell him what you just said?” Balthasar squeaked. “Keep it between us?”
She pursed her lips. “Oh, tell him. I don’t care. I’m sure he’ll have some lovely things to say about me in return. Make sure you laugh at whatever he says. If you don’t laugh at his jokes he gets very sullen and sad.”
She slammed her notebook shut.
“Well, see ya,” was all he could manage. Of the two, Ben was far less intimidating.
Ben hung up the phone and pushed his way out of the bathroom. Not bothering to thank Balthasar, he headed straight for the gym, which would be quiet and empty, he hoped.
The gymnasium. Shining, hardwood floors, basketball goals on both ends, bleachers pulled out from the wall. A trophy case glitters against the far wall.
Sitting on a bleacher looking incredibly defeated was Clay, his head resting in his hands.
Since he was spotted, Ben felt like he had to go sit by his friend. “So. How’d it go?”
“I hope they’re very happy together.”
“Who?”
“Pedro and Hero.”
“Pedro and Hero? That’s not a thing.”
“It is. I saw it with my own two eyes.”
“But. The bro code. He wouldn’t.”
“He did,” Clay pronounced finally.
Ben opened his mouth, but Clay cut him off.
“Can you just, like, leave me alone?”
“Hey, I’m not the one you’re mad at. Don’t take it out on me.”
“Fine. Then I’ll go.” Clay stormed off toward the hallway.
“Poor guy,” Ben muttered to the empty gymnasium. He sat, tapping the bench and listening to the echo. “Class clown,” he shook his head. “She thinks I’m not funny. She wouldn’t. She doesn’t get my humor. Never has.” Tap, tap, tap he went. “Projection. That’s what they call it. From AP Psych. She’s miserable, so she assumes everyone is.” Tap, tap. “And now I’m talking to myself. Don’t know what that’s called. Psychologically.”
The door banged open and Pedro strode in. “Ah, there you are! Where’s Clay?”
“He went that way,” he thumbed toward the halls. “He said you stole Hero from him.”
“What? Me! Never! The bro code!”
“That’s what I said!” The two did one of those high fives that becomes a handshake. “So how did it go?”
With a smirk, Pedro waved his hand dismissively. “I got game for days. The girl is wowed and wooed. And wants Clay to ask her out.”
“Let’s go find Clay and tell him.”
“Alright. What’s up with you? I haven’t seen you this pissed off since…ever.”
“Nothing,” Ben said firmly.
“Cause I passed by Beatrice coming here and she was going on and on that you were starting shit.”
“She! Ah! She…! She was the one talking shit about me, piling on insult after insult. She said I only thought I was funny and that I was worse than a loser, or something like that. She’s mean, just plain mean, like a kid burning ants with a magnifying glass. I don’t want to talk about her. And she makes life hell for me, always talking, talking, talking. The girl never shuts up!”
As they rounded a corner, they just about bumped right into her and Clay.
“Look who it is!” Pedro said, happy to see his friend and set the record straight.
Ben only saw Beatrice and he saw red. “Need me to go back to the gym? Did you forget anything there? In your car? Want me to go pick up burgers across the street or go to your house and do your chores? Anything? Anything to get away from that harpy!” he said clearly and loudly.
“Come on, man. Stay, hang out.”
Ben took one look at Beatrice’s glare and shook his head. “No. I can’t stand her.” With a last, parting look, a look so cold it would freeze July, Ben walked away.
Beatrice stood stock still, watching him go.
Trying to lighten the mood, with Clay facing him and scowling and Beatrice looking off dazed, Pedro said: “Hm. I take it you two won’t be getting back together?”
“Guess not,” Beatrice said quietly. “Anyway, Hero told me you were going to talk to Clay, so…here’s Clay.” She shrugged.
“You seem mad,” Pedro pointed out.
“I’m not,” Clay replied coolly.
“You’re all tense and pale. Are you feeling sick?”
“He’s not mad, he’s not sick, but he’s not happy with you,” Beatrice told him testily. “What kind of game are you playing?”
“No, hey, sorry man, but there’s been a misunderstanding. I did exactly what I told you I would do. I talked to Hero for you. She likes you. She wants you to ask her out!”
“Really?” Clay asked, surprised.
“Is that all you can say?” Beatrice teased.
“I don’t have the words to say how happy that makes me.”
The bell rings and students pour around them like a river flowing around rocks. Hero among them.
Time stands still as the two walk toward each other, smiling tenderly. Somewhere someone nearby plays “golden hour” by JVKE loudly from their phone. Hero and Clay walk toward each other.
“Hey,” Clay said.
“Hi,” Hero replied.
“Do you, um, do you want to go to prom with me?”
“Yes! I would like that.”
“And maybe, before then, we could hang out or whatever.”
“Okay, yeah. I’m free this weekend.”
“Cool.”
“Cool,” Hero agreed.
The couple walked down the hall holding hands, both walking in the wrong direction, but too careful of this new romance to correct the other.
“And we never saw them again,” Beatrice said, snapping Pedro’s attention.
“Right? You know what, Beatrice? You’re not so bad.”
“Yeah, well don’t let it get around. Look at them. Whispering in each other’s ear. So cute. Now my best friend has a boyfriend. Damn. We were going to go to prom, just us girls.”
“I could get you a date, if you want,” he offered.
“Oh yeah?” She raised her eyebrows. “Apparently you’re a good matchmaker. But how about it? Want to go with me?”
“Ha! Sure why not? Want to go to prom with me?” Pedro asked, knowing her answer already.
“Alas, I think you’re out of my league: captain of the basketball team, etc. etc. I was just kidding.”
“You kid around a lot. I think I get you, now.”
“Oh, yeah?”
“You only joke with people you like. So it’s really your silence that means you don’t like someone. Like if you don’t like someone, you just ignore them, is that right?”
Beatrice shrugged. “Whatever. I have to get to French. Au revoir!”
Things were starting to fall into place in Pedro’s mind and he was rejoined by Clay and Hero, now heading the right way thanks in part to Ursula, who had joined them.
“Back so soon?” he mocked them.
“Where did Beatrice go?” Hero asked.
“French class. You know, she’s starting to grow on me, she’s funny.”
“Beatrice?” Ursula asked. “She is. Once you get to know her, yeah. She’s ride or die.”
“But she says she doesn’t want a date to prom?”
“Nope,” Ursula insisted, “No dating until college, she’s convinced.”
“I was thinking,” he argued, “about setting her up with Ben.”
“What! No!” Hero shrieked. “She would never!”
“And he would never,” Clay seconded.
“They would kill each other before they got out of the limo at prom,” Ursula added.
Pedro held up his hands as if warding off their protests. “Prom is still a week away. I can get them together. I have a plan, but I need you three to help me.”
“Count me in!” Ursula cheered, laughing.
“Me, too,” Clay said agreeably, happily, and still looking more at Hero than anyone else.
“Hero?” Pedro asked.
“Anything for Beatrice,” she told them.
“Awesome. Really, he’s a great guy. Honest and loyal. I’ll tell you what to tell her about him to make her fall in love with him. And I know what to say to him to make him fall for her.”
“If we can pull this off…” Hero started.
“Just call me Cupid, baby,” he joked and mimed shooting an arrow. “What could go wrong?”
“So with prom a week away, Hero and Clay officially became a couple. The couple. They went everywhere together that whole week. It was actually sort of disgusting, always holding hands and giggling. Like, come on, you’re in love after like a day?”
“Is that why you starting spreading those rumors about her?” Ms. Marlowe asked.
“It was worse than rumors. And once again it was my bad idea.”
